Bright sequences in "There Was A Father" are;
The field trip in Hakone, Scene 0397, B=0.4403
The father and the son visiting the castle ruin, Scene 0982, B=0.4372
The father and the son fishing in the river, Scene 1401, B=0.4731
The building of the father's office, Scene 2009, B=0.4114
Schoolboys sitting on the bridge, Scene 2436, B=0.4445
The father's last words, Scene 4764, B=0.3914
|Bright Scenes in "There Was A Father"|
Understandably, 5 out of 6 are the (daytime) exterior scenes. There are several spots of dark sequences, three of which are;
The wake session of the dead students, Scene 0623, B=0.1594
The night scene in the temple, Scene 1245, B=0.1744
The night scene in the school, Scene 2538, B=0.1450
|Dark Scenes in "There Was A Father"|
As discussed earlier, the night interior scenes are lacking in sufficient illumination in general, and lighting schemes employed were different from Hollywood counterparts.
In "Late Spring", the bright sequences in the first half are more pronounced;
The trip to Tokyo, Scene 0816, B=0.4606
The bicycle trip to seashore, Scene 1333, B=0.5288
|Bright Scenes in "Late Spring"|
And the darkest scene in the film was;
Noriko contemplaing in the darkness of night, Scene 5311, B=0.0907
Superficially, the differences in bright scenes (daytime exterior) and dark scenes (nighttime interior) seem to correspond to those of "There Was A Father". But I think if you look at "Late Spring" closely, the dark scenes are placed in quite a strategic manner. "Late Spring" is the post-war production and shooting conditions were far better than during the war. Though the night interior scenes are still in the darker end of spectrum, it definitely has a different lighting scheme/strategy from those during war. The good example is the shot of Noriko during the dinner (Scene 1828, B=0.2246). Enough lighting is on Noriko, bringing out delicate curves and shades of her fingers, texture of her clothes and complexion of her face.
|Late Spring, Scene 1828|
Let's compare Chishu Ryu in both films. In "Late Spring", Scene 1886 (B=0.1857), the face of Chishu Ryu is illuminated evenly, with slight shades to sculpture his lean face. The same Chishu Ryu is given different shades in "There Was A Father", Scene 3033 (B=0.2422). His stern facial expression aside, the source of light is at far left to give distictively strong contrast. Though overall brightness value is much higher for the scene in "There Was A Father" (much of the bright features are provided by the background), the impression, or the mood, of the frame is not so. In addition, you may notice the loss of the resolution is perceivable in "There Was A Father". Such loss of qualities can easily be attributed to poor duplication of the existing prints.
|Late Spring, Scene 1886|
|There Was A Father, Scene 3033|
The night sequence near the end of "Late Spring", the darkest sequence of the film, affirms the very astute planning for the lighting. The delicate diffusion throws strangely sensual veil on Noriko's face. This leads us to concentrate on Noriko's inner thoughts. However, how hard we try to peer into the inner side of Noriko's mind, how hard we try to solve the puzzle of the vase in the darkness, only fragment of her inner thoughts we can collect is silent void, a big question mark. The audience can attach their own version of interpretation on the vase, Noriko's expression and the silence.
|Late Spring, Scene 5311|
Now, we may say, "we are looking at the bad prints, it's contrasty, it's blurred, of course. There is no point in analyzing bad prints." Or is it?